ICYMI: Federal Judge Rules Against Harsh Requirements For Sick Pennsylvanians To Keep Health Care
11/9/26, 11:00 AM

PENNSYLVANIA — People battling serious illnesses should be able to focus on getting better, not fighting to keep their health insurance. Recently, a federal judge ruled against the harsh requirement that people with qualifying medical conditions to repeatedly prove their illness prevents them from working to qualify for an exemption. The decision is an important step toward protecting people with chronic illnesses, disabilities, and serious medical conditions from having to repeatedly prove they're too sick to work just to keep the health coverage they need. However, it may still be appealed by the Administration.
For Grace, 31, of Cresco, Medicaid is essential to her health, independence, and future. She lives with a genetic mitochondrial disease and suffered a stroke at age 20. Her condition requires significant daily assistance, and Medicaid made it possible for her mother to serve as her full-time paid caregiver. Today, Grace is pursuing a bachelor's degree and working toward a career as a behavioral therapist.
“People who are sick shouldn't have to spend their time fighting to prove how sick they are just to keep their health care,” said Grace. “Medicaid gave me the support I needed to survive my stroke, continue my education, and work toward a future where I can help other people. My illness doesn't define what I'm capable of achieving, but I still need access to care. No one should have to choose between getting better and keeping their health insurance.”
“Imagine going through cancer treatment or managing a serious chronic illness and having to worry about whether you'll lose your health insurance because you missed a deadline or couldn't complete another round of paperwork,” said Rachele Fortier, Executive Director of Affordable Pennsylvania. “People who are sick deserve the time and support to focus on their health, not another bureaucratic hurdle. This ruling is a welcome recognition that people shouldn't have to prove they're too sick to work to get the health care they need.”
The stricter Medicaid requirements are scheduled to take effect in 2027. Affordable Pennsylvania will continue to elevate the voices of Pennsylvanians who depend on Medicaid and advocate for policies that protect access to affordable health care.
###
Affordable Pennsylvania is a Pennsylvania organization focused on holding elected leaders accountable for the decisions they make and their impact on working families. We make sure Pennsylvanians have the facts about how federal policies and votes affect the cost of everyday life, including groceries, health care, child care, utilities and transportation.